SC on Bihar SIR: We will step in if there's mass exclusion of voters
Senior advocate Kapil Sibal and advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for petitioners, once again alleged that people are being left out from the draft list to be published on August 1 by the poll panel
Stating that the Election Commission (EC) is a constitutional authority and it is deemed to act per law, the Supreme Court on Tuesday (July 29) said it will step in if there is mass exclusion in the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar.
A Bench of Justices Surya Kant and Joymalya Bagchi fixed a timeline for considering a batch of pleas challenging the Election Commission's SIR exercise in Bihar, and said that hearing on the issue will be held on August 12 and 13.
Also read: Bihar SIR ground report: BLOs speak on accusations, EC targets, challenges
Senior advocate Kapil Sibal and advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for petitioners, once again alleged that people are being left out from the draft list to be published on August 1 by the poll panel, and they will lose their crucial right to vote.
65 lakh persons to be omitted?
Bhushan said the EC has issued a statement that 65 lakh persons have not submitted the enumeration forms during the SIR process as they are either dead or have permanently shifted elsewhere.
He submitted that these people will have to apply afresh for inclusion in the list.
Also read: SC not stopping SIR rollout; what's in store for Bihar, rest of India? | Capital Beat
Justice Surya Kant said, "The Election Commission of India, being a Constitutional authority, is deemed to act in accordance with the law. If any wrong doing is done, you bring to the notice of the court. We will hear you."
Justice Bagchi told Bhushan, "Your apprehension is that 65 lakh-odd voters will not feature in the draft list. Now ECI is seeking correction in the electoral roll. We are overviewing the process as a judicial authority. If there is mass exclusion, we will immediately step in. You bring 15 people whom they say are dead and are alive."
What Sibal said
Sibal, appearing for RJD MP Manoj Jha, said the EC knows who these 65 lakh people are and if they mention their names in the draft list, no one will have a problem.
"If the draft list is conspicuously silent, you will bring to our notice," Justice Kant said.
Senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, appearing for the poll panel, said that even after the draft list publication, enumeration forms can be filed.
The Bench asked the petitioners and the poll panel to file their written submissions by August 8.
It appointed nodal officers from petitioners side and the Election Commission side for filing written submissions/compilations.
EC told to accept Aadhaar, voter ID
On Monday, underscoring the "presumption of genuineness" of Aadhaar and voter ID, the top court refused to stay the publication of the draft electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar, and said it would once and for all decide pleas against the EC’s SIR of electoral rolls.
It asked the poll panel to continue accepting Aadhaar and voter ID for the SIR exercise in Bihar in compliance with its order, saying both documents had a "presumption of genuineness".
Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for NGO Association for Democratic Reforms, had submitted that the electoral rolls should not be finalised in the interim, pressing for an interim stay on the publication of the draft rolls on August 1.
The apex court, however, referred to the top court's previous order noting the petitioners did not press for an interim relief, which couldn't be allowed now, and said the matter would be interpreted once and for all.
(With agency inputs)