Ratan Tata thought big, bought big, with a keen eye on business integrity

Ratan Tata ran the Tata Group of companies, one of India’s largest business groups, from 1991 to 2012, without being featured among the world’s richest, even as leaders of smaller business groups figured among the world’s mega billionaires.

The Tata Group has operated outside India since Ratanji Tata made a pile of money in opium trade in the late 19th century, but it was Ratan Tata who made Tata a global presence, through strategic acquisitions, savvy consolidation of the Tata brand and its unified projection.

The Tata brand

The Tata brand benefitted every individual group member in terms of name recognition, trust and reliability, and, owing to such trust, a lower cost of capital than what it would have faced as a standalone company outside the group.

Everyone remembers Tata for his ambition to produce a car for a price of Rs 1 lakh, and for his acquisitions of Tetley Tea, Jaguar Land Rover, Corus Steel, and, recently, Air India.

Also read: Employee unrest clouds Tata Sons' ambitious Vistara-Air India merger

TCS was set up in 1969 by Ratan Tata’s predecessor as Tata Group leader, JRD Tata, and FC Kohli ran the firm successfully for long, till 1996. But the Indian IT services industry really took off in the period since, with TCS in the forefront.

Ratan Tata, as the group leader, helped identify capable successors to Kohli, delegated authority to them, and helped them evolve. Even today, TCS remains the group’s cash cow.

Research and innovation

In 2007, an Indian supercomputer, Eka, ranked among the world’s fastest computers. Ratan Tata backed the development of the machine. The commitment to R&D visible in this enterprise did not, however, manifest itself in other parts of the Tata Group.

Also read: Ratan Tata envisioned ‘new India’ propelled by young minds with brilliant ideas

Only very recently have the Tatas taken the lead in research-based innovation, creating an indigenous 5G hardware ecosystem, spearheading research, carried out through a bunch of pioneering startups.

Every industrial group, including the Tatas, shares the blame for India’s R&D expenditure remaining an abysmal 0.64 per cent of GDP, a shade above Gabon’s 0.60 per cent, but shamefully below Israel’s 5.6 per cent, South Korea’s 4.9 per cent, Japan’s 3.3 per cent, America’s 3.46 per cent and China’s 2.65 per cent of GDP.

'Government of Tata-Birla'

In the early years after Independence, Indian Communists, the largest Opposition of the time, characterised the government of India as the government of Tata and Birla.

Times have changed. Today, the government is characterised by the Opposition as the government of Adani and Ambani, even as the Tatas remain one of the largest business groups.

Also read: Admire Ratan Tata? Here are 8 lesser-known things about him

Whatever the merits of this description, the fact remains that the Tatas do not carry the opprobrium that they bend the state to their own ends. This owes not a little to Ratan Tata’s leadership of the group and his style of functioning.

Nano project

The Opposition has valid grounds for pillorying the Tata Group for the role it played in burnishing the business-friendly reputation of the then Chief Minister of Gujarat, Narendra Modi, by moving the Tata Nano project from West Bengal to Gujarat, where the state government welcomed it with open arms and generous concessions, after an agitation against land acquisition for the project in West Bengal made progress difficult.

But no major politician of any party has chosen to harp on that today, in the wake of his demise.

Watch | Remembering Ratan Tata: A potent business baron who touched millions of lives

This is because Tata, as a person and as a business leader, was not overtly political, and made political contributions through a Trust, based on votes secured by parties contending for the donations.

Group consolidation

This does not mean that Rata Tata’s career as leader of the Tata Group was free of controversy.

When he took over from JRD, the group companies were autonomously run by a bunch of powerful satraps, who did not see any reason to be accountable to the group holding company, Tata Sons.

Ratan Tata changed that. He consolidated the different parts — ranging from iron and steel, salt, chemicals and automobiles to hotels and software services — as a tight-knit group, introduced a retirement age of 75 for board positions, and applied that rule to himself.

This got rid of the satraps – although Taj Hotels’ Ajit Kerkar had to go over foreign exchange violations – and made Tata Sons the ultimate arbiter of the fortunes of group companies.

Mistry the manager

When Ratan Tata stepped down in 2012, he was succeeded by Cyrus Mistry, son of Pallonji Mistry, the largest shareholder after the Tata Trusts. He was ousted in 2016. Controversy clouded his removal.

Also read: Cyrus Mistry will be remembered for fighting the Tatas tooth and nail

Mistry was a manager, rather than a leader, choosing to focus on the profits and losses of individual enterprises in the group rather than on the group as a whole, or on the impact of the Tata Group’s actions on the economy as a whole.

To illustrate, when the Tatas forayed into telecom services, floated in collaboration with DoCoMo of Japan, the joint venture agreement included an opportunity for DoCoMo to exit at a pre-fixed price. Mistry took advantage of a technicality in rules governing such exits to wriggle out of making that payment, once the venture floundered.

For India Inc

If it turned out that the Tata Group could not be trusted to honour a joint venture agreement, it would damage the reputation not just of the group but of all of India Inc. Mistry was unmindful of that larger damage.

Also read | Ratan Tata obit: Industry trailblazer, corporate adventurer, boardroom patriarch

Ratan Tata was not. After Mistry’s removal from Tata Son’s chair and later, Board, the payment due to DoCoMo was made good.

Ratan Tata led the Tatas into the manufacture of electronics, and the metal scaffolding of the Boeing 737 Dreamliner that holds together the plane’s carbon fibre fuselage.

Tata Advanced Systems was founded in 2007, and plays a vital role in the indigenisation of Indian defence production.

Chandra, and the future

Ratan Tata entrusted the group's leadership to a non-Tata, N Chandrasekaran. There is no particular reason for the professionally run group to necessarily choose another Tata to head the company in the future.

The Tata Trusts that hold the controlling stake in Tata Sons can, in theory, choose another Tata to lead the group, but as the group turns ever more diverse and complex, professional leadership is at a premium.

Thus, the Tatas might well prove to be the first Indian group to cede leadership to merit rather than prefer genes.

Vast legacy

When Jamshedji Tata founded the Indian Iron and Steel Company in 1907, it was a qualitative step forward for Indian business. The Tatas have also pioneered philanthropy, setting up advanced research institutions.

Ratan Tata has extended that legacy, and taken it another qualitative step forward.